Should I use a web application?
Posted in Tips on June 16th, 2009 by Maxim – Comments OffNowadays, new web applications—websites that function like software that you would ordinarily install on your computer—pop up every day. Some, like Facebook and Twitter, are truly innovative and couldn’t have been conceived before the popularity of the Web. Others, like Picnik and GMail, take functions that have historically lived on the computer desktop and made them available (often for free) through a web browser. Should you use these new web applications or stick with the tried-and-true PC versions?
Advantages of web applications:
- No need to install anything on your computer. You just use your browser and an Internet connection. Also no need for installing updates, upgrading to new versions, etc.
- The application, and in my cases your data, are accessible from any computer with an Internet connection.
- The application and your data are often backed up and secured well.
- Data can often be shared easily with others.
- If anything happens to your computer or you get a new one, you don’t have to do anything except log in to the website from a new computer.
Disadvantages of web applications:
- Some web applications may be slower and/or less full-featured than their computer counterparts.
- If your Internet connection is slow or unreliable, your access to the applications will be, too.
- In some cases, you will not be able to access your data without an Internet connection (for example, if you are on a plane with your laptop). Some web applications, however, do allow syncing data for offline use.
- You have to entrust your data, including its privacy and security to a company that you may not have any control over. In some cases, your activity may be tracked or sold for marketing purposes. This is usually disclosed in a privacy policy.
- If the company goes out of business or decides to change or cancel its product, you’ll need to find a new application. In extreme cases, you may lose access to your data, as well. (This can sometimes be avoided by backing up a copy of your data onto your computer.)
So, with all that, does it make sense to use a web application? It depends on your needs. Some applications, like e-mail, lend themselves very well to web applications, thus the popularity of GMail, Hotmail, Yahoo! Mail, and others. This is because it’s convenient to access your e-mail from any browser and always have access to all your old mail, your address book, and so on. In contrast, something like an online photo editor, such as Picnik, or an online photo sharing and organizing site like flickr, may not be of interest if all you want to do is edit and organize photos on your computer. (A better solution might be Picasa, which also allows you to create web albums to share with friends and family. Just remember to back up your photos once in a while, in case anything happens to your computer.)
Some applications, like Google Docs, are helpful for special situations. For example, while Microsoft Word is a far more sophisticated word processor than the Google Docs word processor, Google Docs allows you to easily share and/or collaborate on a document with other folks online. Then there are the web applications, like previously mentioned Facebook and Twitter, which have no equivalents on the desktop.
If you’ve had an experience, whether positive or negative, using web applications, feel free to share it in the comments!
